optimal vehicle ownership duration
Financial Planning

The Best Time to Keep a Car: A Frugal Guide

0 0
Read Time:11 Minute, 48 Second

Last updated: · By Laura Bennett

Car ownership costs add up faster than many families expect. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that average annual household transportation spending was $13,174 in 2023, including $5,539 on vehicle purchases and $3,845 on other vehicle expenses such as insurance, maintenance, and repairs. For most households, keeping a car three to six years is a practical planning window, but the right point depends on your repair history, loan balance, and family needs. This guide explains where the money goes, when to keep, sell, or buy, and how to lower your costs.

Key Takeaways

  • In 2023, average annual household transportation spending was $13,174, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
  • In 2022, car-owning households earning under $25,000 spent 38% of after-tax income on transportation, compared with 5% for similar households without a vehicle.
  • In 2023, the lowest-income group spent about $1,411 per vehicle on financing, insurance, and repairs, versus $1,863 for the highest-income group.
  • Federal Highway Administration data from 2021 put average fuel use at about 434 gallons per year for a short-wheelbase light-duty vehicle.
  • Keeping a car long enough to get past the steepest early depreciation is a common planning rule, but your repair record and budget should drive the final decision.

What Are Car Ownership Costs?

Car ownership costs are the total expenses of keeping a vehicle over time, including purchase or loan payments, depreciation, insurance, fuel, routine maintenance, repairs, registration, and taxes. Depreciation is the drop in a vehicle’s market value as it ages and accumulates miles. Many owners overlook it because it is not a bill, but it is often the largest single cost of owning a new car.

The federal government tracks these costs at the household level. The table below shows the 2023 averages from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Those figures are per household, not per vehicle, and the total also includes other transportation spending, such as fuel and public transit, that the table does not itemize.

Category (2023 annual average, per household) Amount
Total transportation spending $13,174
Vehicle purchases $5,539
Other vehicle expenses (insurance, maintenance, repairs, and similar costs) $3,845

How Long Should You Keep a Car to Save Money?

For many households, keeping a car three to six years is a practical balance. That window generally lets you get past the steepest early depreciation while the car is still before the stage when repair bills tend to rise. It is a rule of thumb, not a research-backed threshold, so the best point varies by model, mileage, and condition.

Why Does Depreciation Matter for Ownership Costs?

New vehicles usually lose value fastest in their first years. An owner who sells in year one or two often absorbs the largest share of that loss. Holding the car longer spreads the cost across more years of use.

Mileage also affects resale value. Lower-mileage vehicles are generally easier to sell, so track your odometer when you plan a sale. Review your car insurance too, because premiums may not fall as quickly as the car’s value.

When Do Repair Costs Outweigh the Car’s Value?

Compare the expected repair bill with the car’s current market value and any remaining loan payments. If one repair approaches the value of the car, replacing it may cost less over the next few years. Use this process to decide:

  1. Keep a log of every repair, with the date, mileage, and cost.
  2. Get a written estimate from an independent mechanic before approving major work.
  3. Look up the car’s current private-party or trade-in value and compare it with the repair estimate.
  4. Add up upcoming maintenance the car is due for, such as brakes or tires.
  5. Repair the car if it is otherwise reliable and the cost is a small fraction of its value. Replace it if repairs keep recurring.

Do not delay repairs that affect safety, such as brakes, steering, or tires. A licensed mechanic can tell you whether a problem is urgent.

How Do Ownership Costs Affect Lower-Income Families?

Car ownership takes a much larger share of income for lower-income households. Bureau of Transportation Statistics data for 2022 found that car-owning households earning under $25,000 spent 38% of after-tax income on transportation, while similar households without a vehicle spent 5%. That gap shows how much a car raises the cost burden.

family vehicle safety considerations

Per-vehicle spending also differs by income. In 2023, the lowest-income quintile spent about $1,411 per vehicle on financing, insurance, and repairs, compared with $1,863 for the highest-income group. Fuel spending was about $1,324 versus $1,514. Lower-income families spent less in dollars, but these averages do not capture the strain of a budget already stretched thin.

How Much Does Fuel Add to Car Ownership Costs?

Fuel is one of the more predictable running costs because you can estimate it from your mileage and fuel economy. Federal Highway Administration data for 2021 put average fuel consumption at about 434 gallons per year for a short-wheelbase light-duty vehicle and about 637 gallons for a long-wheelbase vehicle. Those figures are useful baselines for your own estimate.

For illustration only, at an assumed price of $3.50 per gallon, 434 gallons would cost about $1,519 per year, and 637 gallons would cost about $2,230. Gas prices change, so replace the assumed figure with your local price. You can also track your actual fuel use for a month to see how close your car comes to the baseline.

Is Buying a Used Car Cheaper Than Buying New?

Often, yes. A used car has already passed its steepest early depreciation, so the first owner has absorbed much of that loss. The actual savings depend on the model, age, condition, and local market, and none of the sources used for this guide quantify the gap, so compare listings for the exact model you want.

efficient vehicle maintenance timing

Certified pre-owned programs can add value because many include inspections and extended warranties. Coverage terms vary by manufacturer and dealer, so read the warranty and inspection checklist before you sign. For a deeper look at why more buyers are choosing used vehicles and how to find a good one, read our guide to finding a strong used-car deal.

Always get a pre-purchase inspection from an independent mechanic before buying a used car. The cost is usually modest compared with the repairs it can reveal. Also check the vehicle’s recall history before you buy.

When Is the Best Time to Buy a Car?

Timing can affect price, but the effect is usually modest and not guaranteed. Dealers often push to meet monthly, quarterly, and year-end sales targets, and they may clear out outgoing models before new ones arrive. Shopping near those points can give you more room to negotiate, but compare offers at any time of year.

Reduce pressure and improve your position with these habits:

  • Get preapproved for a loan from your bank or credit union before visiting a dealer.
  • Ask several dealers for an out-the-door price in writing, including taxes and fees.
  • Negotiate the vehicle price separately from any trade-in value or monthly payment.
  • Walk away if the numbers do not fit your budget.

When Is the Best Time to Sell a Car?

The best time to sell is usually before major repairs come due and while mileage is still moderate. Many sellers report that spring and early summer draw more buyers, but check your local market before you list. A private sale often brings more money than a trade-in, though it takes more effort.

Before you sell, get trade-in quotes from at least two dealers and compare them with private-party listings for similar cars. Document your maintenance records, since they can support the asking price.

How Can You Control Maintenance and Insurance Costs?

Preventive maintenance is usually cheaper than emergency repairs. Follow the schedule in your owner’s manual for oil changes, tire rotations, and other services. Put the schedule on your calendar and set aside a monthly amount for predictable costs.

Review your insurance at least once a year and after any major change in the car’s value. As a vehicle ages, comparing the premium with the car’s worth can show whether certain optional coverages still make sense. Ask an insurance agent to explain your options, and compare quotes from several carriers.

How Do Family Needs Change the Math?

Family size, car seats, and teen drivers can change which vehicle makes sense and when to replace it. Larger vehicles often cost more to buy, insure, and fuel, so compare total ownership costs, not just the sticker price. If you are planning for future children, see our guide on planning finances around family size and growth.

Safety should come first when you choose a family vehicle. Look up crash-test ratings from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) for any model you are considering. Advanced features such as automatic emergency braking can matter most for teen drivers, so compare which trim levels include them.

Cut Your Car Ownership Costs: A Checklist

Use this checklist each year to keep your car costs in line. Many of the same habits that lower everyday spending also apply to transportation. Our everyday frugal living tips for saving money cover more ideas for trimming routine expenses.

  • Track every car-related expense in one place for at least three months.
  • Compare your total yearly cost with the BLS averages to see where you stand.
  • Estimate fuel costs using your actual mileage and local gas prices.
  • Keep a repair log and compare major repair quotes with the car’s value.
  • Get a yearly insurance quote review.
  • Plan your next purchase or sale before a major repair is due.
  • Check your budget with a 50/30/20 budget calculator to see how much room your car payment leaves each month.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to own a car per year?

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported average annual household transportation spending of $13,174 in 2023. That figure covers all household transportation, not one vehicle, and it includes purchases, insurance, maintenance, and repairs. Your actual cost depends on the car, your driving, your location, and whether you finance it.

How long should I keep my car?

Three to six years is a common planning window for many households. It can help you avoid the steepest early depreciation and the rising repair costs that often come later. The right answer depends on your repair history, loan balance, and family needs.

Is it cheaper to buy a used car?

Often, yes, because the first owner absorbs much of the early depreciation. Savings vary by model and condition, so compare prices for the exact vehicle you want. Always get an independent pre-purchase inspection before you buy.

When should I replace my car instead of repairing it?

Consider replacing the car when repair estimates approach its market value or when repairs keep recurring. Compare the estimate with the car’s current resale value and your remaining loan balance. Do not delay safety-related repairs while you decide.

Should I get professional advice before buying a car?

Yes, when a purchase would strain your budget. An independent mechanic can assess a used car’s condition, and a nonprofit credit counselor or fee-only financial planner can review your loan options. These professionals can give advice specific to your situation, which general guides cannot.

Conclusion

Car ownership costs go well beyond the purchase price, and the biggest savings usually come from planning ahead. Track your expenses, time your repairs, sales, and purchases with care, and compare total costs before making a decision. Keeping your car a sensible length of time and buying used when it fits your needs can keep more money in your budget.

This article is general information, not financial advice. Prices and deals change: check current terms before you buy. Read our financial disclaimer and editorial policy.

About Post Author

Laura Bennett

Laura Bennett is the pen name under which the Frugal Living and Having Fun team writes and edits its guides. The focus is everyday frugality: budgeting, groceries and meal planning, cutting bills, buying used and having fun for less, with facts and figures linked to their sources. Laura Bennett is not a financial advisor, so nothing here is financial advice; read our editorial policy (frugallivingandhavingfun.com/editorial-policy/) and disclaimer (frugallivingandhavingfun.com/financial-disclaimer/).
Happy
Happy
0 %
Sad
Sad
0 %
Excited
Excited
0 %
Sleepy
Sleepy
0 %
Angry
Angry
0 %
Surprise
Surprise
0 %

Laura Bennett is the pen name under which the Frugal Living and Having Fun team writes and edits its guides. The focus is everyday frugality: budgeting, groceries and meal planning, cutting bills, buying used and having fun for less, with facts and figures linked to their sources. Laura Bennett is not a financial advisor, so nothing here is financial advice; read our editorial policy (frugallivingandhavingfun.com/editorial-policy/) and disclaimer (frugallivingandhavingfun.com/financial-disclaimer/).